0010078: Wording of RQ9.1 - MantisBT

10000-015: Safety
- - All Projects
  - .NET API
  - Certification
  - Compliance Test Tool (CTT) COM Classic
  - Compliance Test Tool (CTT) Unified Architecture
  - CTT UA Binary
  - CTT UA Help
  - CTT UA Package
  - CTT UA Scripts
  - CTT UA Test Case
  - OPC Analyzer
  - Safety Compliance Test Tool (UASCTT)
  - UASCTT Documentation
  - UASCTT Software
  - Specifications
  - Classic DA Client
  - Classic DA Server
  - Safety Test Document
  - UA Client - Certification tests
  - UA Server - Certification tests
  - COM/XML Sample Code
  - COM-AE Sample Code
  - COM-DA Sample Code
  - COM-HDA Sample Code
  - XML-DA Sample Code
  - Core Components
  - OpenSCS
  - UA
  - Field eXchange (UAFX)
  - Part 80: UAFX Overview and Concepts
  - Part 81: UAFX Connecting Devices and Information Model
  - Part 82: UAFX Networking
  - Part 83: UAFX Offline Engineering
  - Part 84: UAFX Profiles
  - UAFX Nodeset
  - UAFX Testing (CTT)
  - Information Models
  - 10000-100: Devices
  - 10000-110: Asset Management Basics
  - 10000-200: Industrial Automation - Basics
  - 10000-210: Industrial Automation - Relative Spatial Location
  - 10020: Analyzer Device Integration (ADI)
  - 10030: ISA-95
  - 10031: ISA 95 Job Control
  - 10040: IEC 61850
  - 11020: Companion Spec Template
  - 30000: PLCopen
  - 30010: AutoID
  - 30020: MDIS
  - 30030: BACnet
  - 30040: AutomationML
  - 30050: PackML
  - 30060: TMC
  - 30070: MTConnect
  - 30081: PADIM
  - 30090: FDT
  - 30110: Powerlink
  - 30120: IO-Link
  - 30130: CCLink (CSP+ForMachine)
  - 30140: PROFINET
  - 30170: ODVA-CIP
  - 30170: ODVA-CIP: 01: Promises
  - 30170: ODVA-CIP: 02: User Stories
  - 30170: ODVA-CIP: 03: Requirements
  - 30200: Commercial Kitchen Equipment
  - 30250: DEXPI
  - 30270: I4AAS
  - 30400: UA Cloud LIbrary
  - 34100: Energy Consumption Management
  - 40001: Machinery
  - 40010: Robotics
  - 40010-1: Robotics-1: Vertical integration
  - 400nn: PlasticsRubber
  - 40077: PlasticsRubber IMM2MES
  - 40082-1: PlasticsRubber TCD
  - 40082-2: PlasticsRubber HotRunner
  - 40082-3: PlasticsRubber LDS
  - 40082-5: PlasticsRubber Moulds
  - 40083: PlasticsRubber
  - 40083: PlasticsRubber GeneralTypes
  - 40084: PlasticsRubber Extrusion
  - 40084-10: PlasticsRubber Extrusion Calibrator
  - 40084-11: PlasticsRubber Extrusion Corrugator
  - 40084-12: PlasticsRubber Extrusion Calender
  - 40084-1: PlasticsRubber Extrusion GeneralTypes
  - 40084-2: PlasticsRubber Extrusion ExtrusionLine
  - 40084-3: PlasticsRubber Extrusion Extruder
  - 40084-4: PlasticsRubber Extrusion HaulOff
  - 40084-5: PlasticsRubber Extrusion MeltPump
  - 40084-6: PlasticsRubber Extrusion Filter
  - 40084-7: PlasticsRubber Extrusion Die
  - 40084-8: PlasticsRubber Extrusion Pelletizer
  - 40084-9: PlasticsRubber Extrusion Cutter
  - 40100: Machine Vision
  - 40100-1: MachineVision-1: Control and more
  - 40200: Weighing Technology
  - 40210: Geometric Measuring Systems
  - 40223: Pumps and Vacuum Pumps
  - 40250: Compressed Air
  - 40301: Flat Glass
  - 40351: High Pressure Die Casting (HPDC)
  - 40450: Joining
  - 40450-1: IJT Joining System – Base
  - 40451: Tightening
  - 40451-1: IJT Tightening System – General
  - 40501: MachineTool
  - 40501-1: MachineTool-1: Monitoring and Job
  - 40502: CNC
  - 40550: Woodworking Machinery
  - 4056n: Mining
  - 40560: Mining General
  - 40561: Mining Extraction Equipment
  - 40562: Mining Loading Equipment
  - 40563: Mining Transport And Dumping Equipment
  - 40564: Mining Mineral Processing Equipment
  - 40565: Mining Development And Support Equipment
  - 40566: Mining Monitoring And Supervision Services
  - 40567: Mining PELO Services
  - 40569: Mining Application And Use Cases
  - 40701: Cleaning-Pretreatment Surface Technology
  - UA Specification
  - 10000-001: Concepts
  - 10000-002: Security
  - 10000-003: Address Space
  - 10000-004: Services
  - 10000-005: Information Model
  - 10000-006: Mappings
  - 10000-007: Profiles
  - 10000-008: Data Access
  - 10000-009: Alarms and Conditions
  - 10000-010: Programs
  - 10000-011: Historical Access
  - 10000-012: Discovery
  - 10000-013: Aggregates
  - 10000-014: PubSub
  - 10000-015: Safety
  - UA Safety Stack
  - UA Safety Stack - Documentation
  - UA Safety Stack - Source Code
  - 10000-016: State Machines
  - 10000-017: Alias Names
  - 10000-018: Role-Based Security
  - 10000-019: Dictionary Reference
  - 10000-020: File Transfer
  - 10000-021: Device Onboarding
  - 10000-022: Base Network Model
  - 10000-023: Common ReferenceTypes
  - 10000-024: Scheduler
  - 10000-025: ObjectSerialization
  - 10000-110: Asset Management Basics
  - 10000-120: XML Data Type Mapping
  - 10000-200: Industrial Automation - Basics
  - 10000-210: Industrial Automation - Relative Spatial Location
  - Code Generators
  - ModelValidator
  - Feature Requests
  - NodeSets, XSDs and Generated Code
  - Website
  - IOP App
  - Online Reference
  - Profiles Application
  - Teams
  - Whitepapers - 22***
  - OPC-11030: UA Modelling Best Practices
  - Wireshark plug-in
anonymous

ID	Project	Category	View Status	Date Submitted	Last Update

0010078	10000-015: Safety	Spec	public	2024-12-11 10:08	2025-03-04 14:04

Reporter	Christian Eitner	Assigned To	Christian Eitner
Priority	normal	Severity	minor	Reproducibility	always
Status	assigned	Resolution	open
Product Version	1.05.04
Target Version	?.??

Summary	0010078: Wording of RQ9.1
Description	rephrase so that the intention of the requirement is clear using a safety-related non-volatile memory for the IDs fulfills the intention but also give examples of why an automatic, non-safety-related mechanism for retrieving and using IDs could potentially be dangerous
Additional Information	2025-03-04 first draft
Tags	No tags attached.

Commit Version

Date Modified	Username	Field	Change
2024-12-11 10:08	Christian Eitner	New Issue
2024-12-11 10:08	Christian Eitner	Status	new => assigned
2024-12-11 10:08	Christian Eitner	Assigned To	=> Christian Eitner
2025-03-04 14:04	Christian Eitner	Additional Information Updated